FOCUS POINT: ALWAYS ACT IN THE ‘BEST INTERESTS’

Written on the 9 August 2012

FOCUS POINT: ALWAYS ACT IN THE ‘BEST INTERESTS’

LAST month’s article discussed the importance of ensuring that the perceptions held by a company’s board of directors of the value inherent in the company were aligned with the perceptions held by the shareholders.

The article examined this point in the context of PEP’s hostile takeover offer for Spotless Group Limited.

An important factor in the success of PEP’s offer for Spotless was, arguably, the role played by Simon Marais’s Orbis Investment Management. Orbis was both a supporter of PEP’s bid and an intermediary between PEP and the Spotless board.

The significant influence that active fund managers can have on board deliberations was evident again in the events that led to Echo Entertainment Group Limited announcing that its chairman John Story (pictured) had resigned from the Echo board.

In this instance, it is interesting to note the role played by Perpetual Limited in the matter.

Attack on Echo

The announcement by Echo on June 8 that Story had resigned as a director followed a sustained media blitz by James Packer’s Crown Limited. The placement of full page advertisements in newspapers around the country came in conjunction with a request by Crown for an extraordinary general meeting of Echo’s shareholders to remove Story as a director and chair of the board, and appoint Crown’s choice, Jeff Kennett, to the Echo board.

Packer’s main claim against Story, as contained in a letter from Crown to other Echo shareholders and published in the newspaper advertising, was that under Story’s leadership, Echo had significantly underperformed. Crown also claimed that Story had failed to manage Echo’s regulatory risk and key relationships with government authorities.

It was not clear from Echo’s public announcements what was discussed at the board meeting before the surprise resignation. But noting that directors do not have the power to remove fellow directors who have been appointed by shareholders, it appears that a “vote of confidence" was taken which resulted in Story’s resignation.

Packer’s tactics were not entirely new to the Australian market and were reminiscent of Solomon Lew’s 2002 newspaper and telemarketing campaign for the contested Coles Myer board seats.

What is interesting in this case is the relative short time it took for Packer’s campaign to be successful.

Rules of governance

While it appears that Story was of the view that his removal was a matter that should be considered by Echo’s shareholders, the company’s board took the view that the on-going disruption caused by Packer’s campaign was damaging to Echo and not in the best interests of shareholders.

Acting in ‘best interests’ is fundamental for any director It remains to be seen what Packer’s ultimate intention is for Crown’s holding in Echo.

Similarly, only time will tell whether Story’s resignation proves to be in the best interests of Echo’s shareholders.

But in both the Spotless and Echo examples, each board ultimately took the view that prolonged engagement/resistance was not in the best interests of the company and its shareholders.

In these circumstances, it is important to remember that the fundamental obligation of directors when exercising their powers or discharging their responsibilities, is that they must do so in good faith and in the best interest of the company.

A determination as to whether something is in the best interests of the company will be largely fact specific.

However, it is important for directors to remember that this obligation is primarily owed to the company as a commercial entity, and not necessarily its shareholders.


Latest News

SLATER & GORDON AND MAURICE BLACKBURN SHOWDOWN IN BELLAMY'S CLASS ACTION

FIERCE rivals Slater & Gordon (ASX: SGH) and Maurice Blackburn have secured funding for class actions against Bel...

WHY VIDEO IS A "GIVEN" FOR BUSINESS

IN TODAY's digital-driven world, video is king and if used right, it can push a company's brand and brand ...

BRAMBLES TUMBLES AFTER REDUCING GUIDANCE

BRAMBLES (ASX: BXB) will miss its first-half guidance due to cost pressures at its North America business.

The com...

VILLAGE ROADSHOW PARKS HURT BY DREAMWORLD TRAGEDY

QUEENSLAND visitors to Village Roadshow (ASX: VRL) theme parks have declined 12 per cent in the wake of four deaths a...

Related News

CARSALES CEO RETIRES AS NEW COMPETITOR COX FINALISES MERGER

CARSALES will have a new CEO as it takes on a fresh challenger to its crown as the dominant online car sales portal i...

BUSINESS CONFIDENCE AT A SIX-YEAR HIGH

SMALL and medium businesses have entered 2017 with their confidence at a six-year high, building on strong gains m...

CONSUMERS PESSIMISTIC ENTERING 2017

CONSUMER confidence remains at its weakest point since April 2016, according to the latest Westpac Melbourne Institut...

RISE OF STARTUP SUPPORT PROGRAMS NOT AS ROSY AT IT SEEMS

ENTREPRENEURIAL cultivation companies in Australia are appearing quickly, but questions have been raised about whe...

Contact us

Email News Update Sign Up Contact Details
Subscriptions

PO Box 2087
Brisbane QLD 4001

LoginTell a FriendSign Up to Newsletter