COURT RULING THREATENS SUNLAND PROFIT

Written on the 14 September 2012

COURT RULING THREATENS SUNLAND PROFIT

SUNLAND Group’s profit for the last financial year is in danger of being all-but wiped out by a court decision against the company today.

The Victorian Supreme Court awarded special costs against Sunland in its case against developers Matthew Joyce and Angus Reed over a property deal that went wrong.

Sunland had claimed the pair deceptively persuaded it to pay a $14 million “introductory fee” for control of a sought-after plot of waterfront land in the emirate of Dubai in the Middle East.

Justice Clyde Croft dismissed that claim in June.

Today, Justice Croft issued a written ruling in which he found Sunland Group had proceeded with its claim for an “ulterior motive” and “the flaw in the case in this respect must have been readily evident to Sunland at the outset.’’

“Sunland chose to pursue . . . a hopeless case and one which must have been quite evidently hopeless to Sunland itself,’’ Justice Croft wrote in his ruling.

He awarded costs against Sunland, estimated by legal experts to be in the range of $10 million.

Publicly-listed Sunland Group recently recorded a profit of $14 million for FY2011-12.

Justice Croft’s ruling against Sunland Group was highly critical of company founder Soheil Abedian (pictured) and executive David Brown.

Justice Croft says claims were made in order to safeguard the company and its representatives against legal action in Dubai at the expense of Joyce, who has spent three years under house arrest in the United Arab Emirates.

Sunland Group has announced it will appeal Justice Croft's June decision on "extensive grounds", and is considering its options in regards to costs. The company’s share price was down 0.55 per cent to $0.91 late this afternoon.


Latest News

SUPER RETAIL GROUP SAYS GOODBYE TO AMART SPORTS BRAND

A BRAND synonymous with Australian sporting goods, Amart Sports, will be retired from 1 November 2017. Super R...

SUPREME COURT GRANTS LEAVE FOR CLASS ACTION AGAINST DICK SMITH

A CLASS action law suit against Dick Smith has been given the green light for shareholders impacted by the company...

TECHNOLOGYONE SAYS IT WILL SUE BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL FOR $50M IF IT TERMINATES CONTRACT

ENTERPRISE software company TechnologyOne (ASX: TNE) has threatened to sue Brisbane City Council (BCC) for more than ...

WESTPAC LOOKING TO SELL HASTINGS TO CHARTER HALL

Westpac Group (ASX: WBC) has entered discussions with property investment group Charter Hall (ASX: CHC) to sell Ha...

Related News

SUPER RETAIL GROUP SAYS GOODBYE TO AMART SPORTS BRAND

A BRAND synonymous with Australian sporting goods, Amart Sports, will be retired from 1 November 2017. Super R...

SUPREME COURT GRANTS LEAVE FOR CLASS ACTION AGAINST DICK SMITH

A CLASS action law suit against Dick Smith has been given the green light for shareholders impacted by the company...

TECHNOLOGYONE SAYS IT WILL SUE BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL FOR $50M IF IT TERMINATES CONTRACT

ENTERPRISE software company TechnologyOne (ASX: TNE) has threatened to sue Brisbane City Council (BCC) for more than ...

WESTPAC LOOKING TO SELL HASTINGS TO CHARTER HALL

Westpac Group (ASX: WBC) has entered discussions with property investment group Charter Hall (ASX: CHC) to sell Ha...

BOOK YOUR FUNCTION SPACE HERE

 

 

 

Contact us

Email News Update Sign Up Contact Details
Subscriptions

PO Box 2087
Brisbane QLD 4001

LoginTell a FriendSign Up to Newsletter