ACCC FIRES WARNING SHOT TO IVF PROVIDERS

Written on the 16 November 2016 by Lin Evlin

ACCC FIRES WARNING SHOT TO IVF PROVIDERS

IVF clinics have been put on notice by consumer watchdog, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) over widespread misleading advertising techniques.

In general, the ACCC expressed concern over the use of technical medical terms in advertising which can confuse the ordinary person, as well as selective reporting of birth success rates.

"The ACCC reviewed website content from all major Australian IVF clinics and found that some made success-rate comparisons without adequate disclosure about, or qualification of, the nature of the data or graphics used to make the claim," says ACCC Commissioner Sarah Court.

"In addition, some IVF clinics used technical terms understood by industry participants but which may be misleading to consumers without further clarification or explanation." 

As an example, some clinics referenced a "clinical pregnancy rate" on their websites which included ectopic pregnancies or pregnancies where no heartbeat was ever detected, whilst an ordinary person would likely take that rate to mean a live birth rate.  The ACCC says that photographs of newborn babies sometimes accompanied these success rate figures on websites.

"The Australian Consumer Law applies to the advertising of all goods or services offered to Australian consumers, including complex medical procedures such as these," Court says.

"The ACCC expects that all IVF clinics will take care to ensure that success-rate comparisons are clear and accurate, and based on data that is explained in non-technical terms so that consumers can rely on it to make informed choices about which IVF clinic to use."

Under Australian Consumer Law, it is illegal for a business to engage in conduct that misleads or deceives or is likely to mislead or deceive consumers.  Penalties for false, misleading or deceptive conduct include fines of up to $1.1 million.

The ACCC's investigation into IVF advertising arose following a complaint from the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency, a regulatory body that receives patient complaints regarding the conduct of medical practitioners.

As part of the review, the ACCC worked with the Fertility Society of Australia, the IVF industry's peak body, to improve industry wide awareness of, and compliance with, the Australian Consumer Law.

The Fertility Society of Australia continues to work with IVF providers to improve transparency about success rate claims and comparisons.

Court says that misleading advertising was widespread throughout the IVF industry and for this reason, the ACCC made the strategic decision to work with IVF clinics to eliminate this behavior rather than engage in litigation. However, she notes that IVF providers are now "squarely on notice."

"The ACCC will continue to monitor complaints received about claims made by IVF providers and won't hesitate to take further action if IVF providers are making false or misleading claims," she says.


Author: Lin Evlin Connect via: Twitter LinkedIn

Latest News

STAFF CHURN BLAMED FOR MCGRATH EARNINGS DOWNGRADE

MCGRATH will fail to meet earnings forecasts after some of its star real estate agents defected to growing Perth firm...

MCBAIN RESIGNS AS BELLAMY'S DIRECTOR WHILE THIRD CLASS ACTION MOVES CLOSER TO SECURING FUNDING

LAURA McBain (pictured) has resigned as a director of Bellamy's Organic (ASX: BAL) today, effective immediatel...

REDBUBBLE TO MISS IPO FORECASTS

REDBUBBLE, the online marketplace for independent artists, will miss a series of forecasts set out in its IPO in its ...

BLUESCOPE CONTINUES STRONG RUN WITH GUIDANCE UPGRADE

BLUESCOPE Steel (ASX: BSL) is trading up 7.51 per cent at $11.16 per share after upgrading its half-year guidance thi...

Related News

CARSALES CEO RETIRES AS NEW COMPETITOR COX FINALISES MERGER

CARSALES will have a new CEO as it takes on a fresh challenger to its crown as the dominant online car sales portal i...

BUSINESS CONFIDENCE AT A SIX-YEAR HIGH

SMALL and medium businesses have entered 2017 with their confidence at a six-year high, building on strong gains m...

CONSUMERS PESSIMISTIC ENTERING 2017

CONSUMER confidence remains at its weakest point since April 2016, according to the latest Westpac Melbourne Institut...

RISE OF STARTUP SUPPORT PROGRAMS NOT AS ROSY AT IT SEEMS

ENTREPRENEURIAL cultivation companies in Australia are appearing quickly, but questions have been raised about whe...

Contact us

Email News Update Sign Up Contact Details
Subscriptions

PO Box 2087
Brisbane QLD 4001

LoginTell a FriendSign Up to Newsletter